Vanguard vs Tastytrade Comparison: Fees, Features, and More (2026)
Vanguard and Tastytrade are two leading discount brokerages offering commission-free stock and ETF trading. Use this head-to-head comparison table to evaluate fees, features, trading tools, and account options to help you decide which broker is right for you in 2026.
| Feature | Vanguard | Tastytrade |
|---|---|---|
| Website | https://investor.vanguard.com/ | https://tastytrade.com/ |
| Broker Type | Full-Service | Discount |
| Trading: Stock & ETF? | Yes | Yes |
| ETF & Stock commission | $0 online | $0 |
| Fractional Shares? | Yes; eligible Vanguard ETFs/dollar-based trading | Yes |
| Percent Allocations? | Yes; Vanguard Digital Advisor/asset-allocation tools | No |
| Crypto Trading? | No | Yes |
| Crypto Fees | Not applicable | 0.75% BTC/ETH; 1% other crypto (open and close) |
| Options Trading? | Yes | Yes |
| Options Fee | $1/contract | $1/contract to open; $0 to close; $10 max per leg |
| Bond Trading Available? | Yes; Treasuries, bonds, and CDs | Yes; U.S. Treasuries/T-bills |
| Receives payment for order flow (PFOF)? | No | Yes |
| Interface: Web trading? | Yes | Yes |
| Desktop trading? | No | Yes; tastytrade Desktop |
| API Trading? | No | Yes; tastytrade Open API |
| Mutual Funds: Offered? | Yes | No |
| Total Mutual Funds | Over 3,000 | None |
| NTF Mutual Funds | Over 1,800 | None |
| Non-NTF Fund Fee | $20 online for transaction-fee funds; $0 for NTF funds | Not applicable |
| Early Redemption Fee? | No | Not applicable |
| Redemption Hold (Days) | 60 days | Not applicable |
| Early Redemption Fee | $50 | Not applicable |
| Accounts: Margin Accounts? | Yes | Yes |
| IRAs Offered? | Yes; Traditional, Roth, SEP, Rollover, and Custodial | Yes; Traditional, Roth, SEP, SIMPLE, and Rollover |
| HSAs Offered? | No | No |
| Money Market Sweep? | Yes; settlement-fund/cash-deposit sweep | Yes; futures/crypto account cash sweeps |
| CDs Offered? | Yes | No |
| Robo-Advisor: Offered | Yes | No |
| Robo-Advisor Service | Vanguard Digital Advisor | None |
| Robo-Advisor Fees | 0.20% all-index; 0.25% active/index mix | Not applicable |
| Basics: Headquarters | Valley Forge, PA | Chicago, IL |
| Year Founded | 1975 | 2017 |
| Clearing Firm | Vanguard Brokerage Services | Apex Clearing |
| Local Branches? | No; phone/online service | No |
| New Account Minimum |
Once you’ve chosen a broker, find high-performing, investable model portfolios at RecipeInvesting.com
Picked a Broker? Now Build Your Perfect Portfolio
Find high-performing, investable model portfolios (Tactical, Strategic, and Managed) at RecipeInvesting.com.
Compare Vanguard to All Brokers
- Compare Vanguard to Ally Invest
- Compare Vanguard to Alpaca
- Compare Vanguard to Axos Invest
- Compare Vanguard to Charles Schwab
- Compare Vanguard to E*Trade
- Compare Vanguard to Fidelity
- Compare Vanguard to Firstrade
- Compare Vanguard to Interactive Brokers
- Compare Vanguard to M1 Finance
- Compare Vanguard to Merrill Edge
- Compare Vanguard to Public.com
- Compare Vanguard to Robinhood
- Compare Vanguard to SoFi Invest
- Compare Vanguard to SogoTrade
- Compare Vanguard to Stash
- Compare Vanguard to Tastytrade
- Compare Vanguard to Tradestation
- Compare Vanguard to Tradier
- Compare Vanguard to WeBull
- Compare Vanguard to ZacksTrade