Tastytrade vs E*Trade Comparison: Fees, Features, and More (2026)

Tastytrade and E*Trade are two leading discount brokerages offering commission-free stock and ETF trading. Use this head-to-head comparison table to evaluate fees, features, trading tools, and account options to help you decide which broker is right for you in 2026.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Tastytrade vs E*Trade (2026)
Feature Tastytrade E*Trade
Website https://tastytrade.com/ https://us.etrade.com/home
Broker Type Discount Online self-directed brokerage (Morgan Stanley; full-service advisors available)
Trading: Stock & ETF? Yes Yes
ETF & Stock commission $0 $0 online US-listed stocks/ETFs (OTC $6.95; other fees may apply)
Fractional Shares? Yes Yes, select listed stocks/ETFs (up to 3 decimals, $5 min notional; expanding)
Percent Allocations? No No (Prebuilt templates with suggested allocations; Core Portfolios managed)
Crypto Trading? Yes Yes; BTC, ETH, SOL via linked zerohash account for US individual brokerage clients.
Crypto Fees 0.75% BTC/ETH; 1% other crypto (open and close) 0.50% of notional value (no spread/markup); charged by zerohash (E*TRADE receives a portion).
Options Trading? Yes Yes
Options Fee $1/contract to open; $0 to close; $10 max per leg $0.65/contract ($0.50 with 30+ trades/quarter) plus regulatory/exchange fees.
Bond Trading Available? Yes; U.S. Treasuries/T-bills Yes; 50,000+ bonds/CDs from many issuers.
Receives payment for order flow (PFOF)? Yes Yes (receives PFOF on NMS stocks, ETFs, and options).
Interface: Web trading? Yes Yes; E*TRADE web/app and Power E*TRADE web/app/desktop.
Desktop trading? Yes; tastytrade Desktop Yes, Power E*TRADE Pro (Windows/Mac download)
API Trading? Yes; tastytrade Open API Yes (Developer Platform REST API; unattended algo orders prohibited)
Mutual Funds: Offered? No Yes
Total Mutual Funds None 5,000+ (6,000+ NTF listed on pricing)
NTF Mutual Funds None 6,000+
Non-NTF Fund Fee Not applicable $0 online (no-load NTF); loads per prospectus
Early Redemption Fee? Not applicable Yes (no E*TRADE fee; fund fees may apply)
Redemption Hold (Days) Not applicable None (0 days); E*TRADE charges no short-term redemption fee (fund prospectus fees may apply)
Early Redemption Fee Not applicable $0 from E*TRADE; fund prospectus redemption fees may apply
Accounts: Margin Accounts? Yes Yes
IRAs Offered? Yes; Traditional, Roth, SEP, SIMPLE, and Rollover Yes (Traditional, Roth, SEP, SIMPLE, others)
HSAs Offered? No No
Money Market Sweep? Yes; futures/crypto account cash sweeps Yes (Bank Deposit Program / BDP)
CDs Offered? No Yes
Robo-Advisor: Offered No Yes
Robo-Advisor Service None Core Portfolios
Robo-Advisor Fees Not applicable 0.30% annual advisory fee ($500 min.)
Basics: Headquarters Chicago, IL Arlington, VA
Year Founded 2017 1982
Clearing Firm Apex Clearing Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC
Local Branches? No No
New Account Minimum $0

Once you’ve chosen a broker, find high-performing, investable model portfolios at RecipeInvesting.com


Picked a Broker? Now Build Your Perfect Portfolio

Find high-performing, investable model portfolios (Tactical, Strategic, and Managed) at RecipeInvesting.com.

Get FREE Access
Recipe Investing Logo

Compare Tastytrade to All Brokers